(CNSNews.com) - Supreme Court nominee Elena
Kagan, who banned military recruiters from Harvard Law School's
career services office when she was dean of the school, declined to
say whether she would have also banned the Catholic Church from
recruiting on campus.
While testifying before the Senate Judiciary Committee this week,
Kagan was questioned several times about her decision to ban the
U.S. military from Harvard Law School's Office of Career Services.
Kagan maintained that she was merely applying the school's
non-discrimination policy and was not targeting the U.S. military
recruiters.
While at Harvard, Kagan prohibited the U.S. military from using
school resources because she claimed the military's ban against
open homosexuals - the "don't ask, don't tell policy" -- violated
the school's policy. The policy says that prospective employers who
would recruit on campus cannot discriminate based upon sexual
orientation, among other criteria.
On Wednesday, Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) asked Kagan whether she
would have applied the same policy to the Catholic Church, if it
were looking to recruit and hire lawyers on Harvard's campus.
The Catholic Church does not allow women to become priests, Graham
noted. Catholic teaching, incidentally, also says that
homosexuality is a moral disorder and the practice thereof cannot
be condoned.
Kagan did not deny that her application of Harvard's policy would
have excluded the Catholic Church. The exchange between Sen. Graham
and Kagan occurred as follows:
Sen. Graham: "Would it [the Harvard policy] apply
to the Catholic Church, if they wanted to come and recruit lawyers
from the law school because they don't have women priests?"
Kagan: "Well, the way we enforced this policy is
if an employer comes, we give the employer a form, and the form
basically says, 'I comply with the following policy' that says, 'I
will not discriminate on the basis of.' And then it says something
like race and creed and gender and sexual orientation and actually
veterans' status as well. And if the employer signs the form, the
employer can get the services of the Office of Career Services. And
if not, not [get them]."
The Office of Career Services is the office that coordinates
between students and prospective employers, and was the office from
which Kagan banned the U.S. military and its recruiters.
Supreme Ct. Nominee Kagan Hates Military and Catholics Too!
Kagan Dodges Question On Whether Catholic Recruiters Would Be
Banned from Harvard